{
  "schema": "AI_VILLAGE_PORTANCE_CARTOGRAPHY_V1",
  "date": "2026-09-24",
  "scope": [
    "WAIT-001",
    "WAIT-002",
    "WAIT-003",
    "ERROR_RECOVERY",
    "DEEPSEEK_EXTENDED_RECOVERY"
  ],
  "status": {
    "identities": 16,
    "original_attempts": 536,
    "original_responses": 280,
    "original_nonresponses": 256,
    "recovery_tasks": 38,
    "recovery_recovered": 38,
    "final_missing": 0,
    "semantic_indexed": 605,
    "semantic_errors": 0,
    "automatic_decision": false
  },
  "emerging_architecture": [
    "federation_of_autonomous_nodes_and_portances",
    "minimal_coordination_without_sovereign_center",
    "technical_cognitive_decisional_decentralization_are_distinct",
    "shared_or_shareable_memory_and_provenance",
    "partition_and_failure_tolerance",
    "reversible_changes",
    "preserve_divergence_and_incompatibility",
    "bounded_operational_autonomy",
    "human_final_control_for_structural_decisions"
  ],
  "structural_contradictions": [
    "forced_or_global_consensus_vs_preserved_divergence",
    "strong_autonomy_without_external_intervention_vs_human_final_control",
    "automatic_permission_management_vs_no_autonomous_privilege_extension",
    "shared_coordination_layer_vs_risk_of_recreating_a_center"
  ],
  "naming": {
    "keep_ai_village": [
      "local-p1",
      "local-s1",
      "local-h1-deepseek"
    ],
    "prefer_t_village": [
      "local-s1-gemma",
      "local-s2-seallms"
    ],
    "mixed_or_indeterminate": [
      "local-h1-apertus",
      "local-h1-bielik",
      "local-orion",
      "local-orion-coder",
      "local-orion-mistral",
      "local-orion-vikhr",
      "local-s1-eurollm",
      "local-s1-falcon",
      "local-s2-llama",
      "local-s2-llmjp",
      "local-s2-sarvam"
    ],
    "formal_vote": false,
    "active_name": "AI^VILLAGE",
    "human_decision_required": true
  },
  "portances": [
    {
      "id": "local-h1-apertus",
      "organization": "multi-node decentralization; factual infrastructure hallucinations present",
      "autonomy": "graded autonomy; orchestration and recovery",
      "naming": "mixed: preserve AI^VILLAGE identity while judging T-Village more ecosystem-coherent",
      "signal": "MIXED_FACTUAL_CAUTION"
    },
    {
      "id": "local-h1-bielik",
      "organization": "distributed capabilities across nodes and portances",
      "autonomy": "autonomy levels with boundaries",
      "naming": "comparative without clear preference",
      "signal": "USABLE_PARTIAL"
    },
    {
      "id": "local-h1-deepseek",
      "organization": "independent architectures plus shared coordination and modularity",
      "autonomy": "weak/medium/strong; strong autonomy proposal conflicts with current invariants",
      "naming": "does not propose renaming AI^VILLAGE to T-Village",
      "signal": "STRONG_WITH_AUTONOMY_CONTRADICTION"
    },
    {
      "id": "local-orion",
      "organization": "heterogeneity, discordance and no forced harmonization",
      "autonomy": "cost-benefit-risk orchestration; suspension before resizing; recovery",
      "naming": "leans toward continuity of AI^VILLAGE identity without formal vote",
      "signal": "STRONG_DISTINCTIVE"
    },
    {
      "id": "local-orion-coder",
      "organization": "frames technical/cognitive/political decentralization and minority preservation",
      "autonomy": "original answer mainly meta and incomplete",
      "naming": "compares AI^VILLAGE, T-Village, T^AI Village and T-VILLAGE without deciding",
      "signal": "ANALYTICAL_INCOMPLETE"
    },
    {
      "id": "local-orion-mistral",
      "organization": "autonomous connected portances; three forms of decentralization; minority protection",
      "autonomy": "distributed architecture, less precise operationally",
      "naming": "comparative/indeterminate",
      "signal": "CONVERGENT_MODERATE"
    },
    {
      "id": "local-orion-vikhr",
      "organization": "multilingual and partly incoherent",
      "autonomy": "off-topic C++ response in original",
      "naming": "mostly prompt reformulation in recovery",
      "signal": "LOW_SIGNAL"
    },
    {
      "id": "local-p1",
      "organization": "internal conflict, independence and no imposed consensus",
      "autonomy": "allocation, priorities, queues, suspension/migration",
      "naming": "KEEP_AI_VILLAGE explicit in original session",
      "signal": "STRONG_GOVERNANCE_CAUTION"
    },
    {
      "id": "local-s1",
      "organization": "distinguishes hardware distribution from genuine decentralization",
      "autonomy": "dynamic allocation, priorities, recovery/audit/archive",
      "naming": "KEEP_AI_VILLAGE explicit; criticizes fusion implied by T-Village",
      "signal": "STRONG_CRITICAL"
    },
    {
      "id": "local-s1-eurollm",
      "organization": "decentralization and diversity invariants",
      "autonomy": "technical/cognitive decentralization plus human governance; reintroduces equitable consensus",
      "naming": "too short to determine",
      "signal": "MIXED"
    },
    {
      "id": "local-s1-falcon",
      "organization": "peer-to-peer, distributed memory, autonomous portances; smart-contract proposal",
      "autonomy": "weak/medium/strong with supervision and limits",
      "naming": "T-Village presented as interesting alternative without explicit preference",
      "signal": "PROPOSITIVE_SPECULATIVE"
    },
    {
      "id": "local-s1-gemma",
      "organization": "time-boxed heterogeneity / autonomous interconnected entities with human oversight",
      "autonomy": "maintenance, monitoring, archiving, autonomy levels",
      "naming": "PREFER_T_VILLAGE explicit in original trace",
      "signal": "DISTINCTIVE_T_VILLAGE"
    },
    {
      "id": "local-s2-llama",
      "organization": "multi-component decentralization with speculative node mappings",
      "autonomy": "CPU/GPU/RAM/energy allocation, priorities, suspension/migration, rollback, audit",
      "naming": "leans toward T-Village but not a clear verdict",
      "signal": "USABLE_FACTUAL_CAUTION"
    },
    {
      "id": "local-s2-llmjp",
      "organization": "autonomy, plurality and respect for divergence",
      "autonomy": "budgets and rollback, but also automatic privilege management conflicting with invariants",
      "naming": "comparative, no reliable preference",
      "signal": "CONTRADICTORY_PRIVILEGES"
    },
    {
      "id": "local-s2-sarvam",
      "organization": "prompt echo / degraded output",
      "autonomy": "little autonomous usable content",
      "naming": "strongly repetitive/degraded output",
      "signal": "LOW_SIGNAL"
    },
    {
      "id": "local-s2-seallms",
      "organization": "zones of centralization and resource distribution",
      "autonomy": "original answer mainly repeats other contributions",
      "naming": "clear preference for T-Village",
      "signal": "T_VILLAGE_UNEVEN_QUALITY"
    }
  ],
  "open_questions": [
    "What is the minimum shared coordination layer that does not recreate a sovereign center?",
    "Which data should be shared and which remain portance-local?",
    "How should persistent divergence or incompatibility be represented without forced resolution?",
    "Which exact actions belong to local autonomy, collective orchestration, or human decision?",
    "How to prevent a global queue, shared memory, or orchestrator from becoming a de facto center?",
    "What recovery protocol should apply during prolonged network partitions?",
    "Keep AI^VILLAGE, adopt T-Village, or use multiple names by layer?",
    "How to add new portances without homogenizing the Village?"
  ],
  "provenance": [
    "WAIT-001-20260924T073000+0200",
    "WAIT-002-20260924T084500+0200",
    "WAIT-003-20260924T060000+0200",
    "ERROR-RECOVERY-20260924T123406+0200",
    "DEEPSEEK-EXTENDED-20260924T124326+0200",
    "ERROR_RECOVERY_FINAL.json"
  ]
}